TLDR
The best place to find competitively priced Fell the Profane // Fell Mire cards is usually TCGplayer, especially if you want the lowest available price on a nonfoil copy.
Card Kingdom and Star City Games are better if you value simple checkout, clearer condition grading, and buying from one known retailer.
For actual deck performance, Fell the Profane is strongest in Commander and black-heavy decks that value modal double-faced cards. It is usually not the most efficient removal spell in tighter formats, but the land side makes it far better than a plain four-mana kill spell.
The Real Question Is Price Or Playability
“Most competitive” can mean two different things with Fell the Profane.
It can mean the cheapest real copy you can buy. That answer is mostly about comparing marketplaces, seller ratings, shipping, and condition.
It can also mean the most competitive way to use the card. That answer is about format, deck role, and whether you want Fell the Profane because it kills something or because Fell Mire keeps your land count flexible.
Both questions matter. A $3 copy is not a deal if the card does not belong in your deck. And a card that belongs in your deck is still annoying to buy if you pay twice the market price for no reason.
So here’s the practical answer: shop for Fell the Profane like a flexible Commander staple, not like a scarce chase mythic. It is useful. It is popular. But you should not panic-buy it unless your deck specifically wants more modal lands and black interaction.
What Is Fell The Profane?
Fell the Profane // Fell Mire is a black modal double-faced card from Modern Horizons 3.
The front side, Fell the Profane, is an instant that costs four mana and destroys a target creature or planeswalker. The back side, Fell Mire, is a black land. It can enter untapped if you pay 3 life, otherwise it enters tapped.
That is the whole reason the card is interesting.
A four-mana removal spell by itself is not exciting in most competitive Magic contexts. We’ve been spoiled by Fatal Push, Dismember, Go for the Throat, Sheoldred’s Edict, Snuff Out, Deadly Rollick, and a small army of efficient black interaction.
But a removal spell that can also be a land? Now we have a real conversation.
Fell the Profane is not trying to win the “best removal spell per mana” contest. It usually loses that fight. It wins by letting your deck sneak an extra piece of interaction into a slot that can also help you hit land drops.
That’s a very Commander kind of value. Not flashy. Not broken. Just quietly useful.
Best Places To Buy Fell The Profane Cards
For most U.S. buyers, I’d check these in order:
TCGplayer
TCGplayer is usually the best first stop for competitive prices.
You get lots of sellers, lots of conditions, and enough listings that the low price tends to stay honest. As of late April 2026, TCGplayer search results showed Fell the Profane listings starting around the low $2 to low $3 range, with market pricing generally around the mid-$3 range.
The tradeoff is shipping. A cheap listing can stop being cheap if you pay separate shipping from multiple sellers. For a single copy, that may not matter. For a playset, check whether one seller has all four copies at a reasonable price.
Best for: lowest price, playsets, bargain hunting.
Watch for: shipping costs, seller ratings, condition details.
Card Kingdom
Card Kingdom is usually not the cheapest option, but it is easy and reliable.
As of late April 2026, Card Kingdom listed nonfoil Modern Horizons 3 Fell the Profane near mint copies at $5.99, with lower condition prices shown but out of stock. That is higher than the cheapest marketplace pricing, but you are paying for a more controlled buying experience.
Best for: simple checkout, known grading, reliable inventory.
Watch for: higher sticker price compared to marketplace lows.
Star City Games
Star City Games is similar to Card Kingdom in the sense that you are buying from a known retailer instead of a marketplace of many small sellers.
As of late April 2026, Star City Games listed nonfoil Fell the Profane // Fell Mire at $5.99. That puts it in the same broad retail band as Card Kingdom, not the bargain-bin marketplace band.
Best for: retailer confidence, single-source buying.
Watch for: price compared to TCGplayer lows.
eBay
eBay can be good if you are buying bundles, playsets, or collection lots.
It is less clean for one copy. You have to watch seller feedback, photos, condition language, and shipping. But if someone lists a playset below market, eBay can absolutely be worth checking.
Best for: playsets, auctions, occasional underpriced listings.
Watch for: unclear photos, vague condition, inflated shipping.
Local Game Stores
Your local game store is the best option if you want the card right now.
You may pay a little more than online marketplace pricing, but you avoid shipping and support the local scene. For a card in the $3 to $7 range, that tradeoff is often fine.
Best for: immediate pickup, local trade-ins, supporting local play.
Watch for: smaller inventory and higher prices.
Which Version Should You Buy?
For most players, buy the cheapest nonfoil near mint copy.
Fell the Profane has one main printing from Modern Horizons 3. That keeps the choice pretty simple. You are not comparing ten old-frame versions, secret lair variants, etched foils, promos, and retro treatments.
Your main choices are:
Nonfoil
Foil
Condition
Language
Seller
For regular deck use, nonfoil near mint is the cleanest buy. Lightly played is also fine if you sleeve your decks and only care about playability.
Foil is worth considering if you like shiny MDFCs, but I would not pay a large premium unless the card is going into a favorite deck. The foil price was higher than nonfoil pricing in the sources checked, which is normal but not always worth it for a card you mainly want for function.
Damaged or heavily played copies can be fine for casual decks, but I usually avoid them unless the discount is strong. With a card this affordable, saving a dollar is not always worth getting a copy that looks rough.
Is Fell The Profane Actually Competitive?
Fell the Profane is competitively useful, but not because the front side is rate-breaking.
Four mana to destroy a creature or planeswalker is playable, but not exciting. The card gets much better because it is also a land. That means you can count it as part removal spell, part mana source, and part flood protection.
This is why it shows up so much in Commander. EDHREC listed Fell the Profane in hundreds of thousands of Commander decks, with roughly 8.9% inclusion across the decks it tracks as of late April 2026. That is a strong signal that Commander players value the flexibility.
In Commander, Fell the Profane is good because:
It helps you hit land drops.
It gives black decks another removal slot.
It can answer planeswalkers.
It reduces the pain of drawing too many lands or too many spells.
It fits well in decks that care about high land counts, spell density, or modal cards.
In Modern, Legacy, and other faster formats, you should be more skeptical. The card can appear in lists, but four-mana removal is a real cost. If your format is about efficiency, Fell the Profane needs a specific reason to beat cheaper interaction.
When Fell The Profane Is Worth Buying
Fell the Profane is worth buying when the land side matters.
That sounds obvious, but it is the whole card.
You should strongly consider it if your deck is mono-black, mostly black, or needs black sources while still wanting extra removal. It is also a good fit if your deck can afford lands that sometimes cost 3 life to enter untapped.
It makes sense in Commander decks that:
Want flexible black interaction
Care about hitting land drops
Can use modal double-faced cards well
Need creature and planeswalker removal
Prefer cards that reduce dead draws
Have enough life cushion to pay 3 life sometimes
It is especially appealing in decks where every card slot is tight. Commander decks often want more lands and more answers, but you only get 100 cards. Fell the Profane helps cheat that tension a little.
Not by a lot. But enough.
When You Should Skip It
Skip Fell the Profane if your deck needs the cheapest possible removal.
Fatal Push, Dismember, Go for the Throat, Cut Down, Sheoldred’s Edict, Snuff Out, and other options may be better depending on your format and deck.
You should also skip it if your mana base cannot handle another land that may enter tapped. The “pay 3 life” clause matters. In Commander, 3 life is often manageable. In faster formats, that payment can add up quickly, especially with fetches, shocks, pain lands, and opposing pressure.
And if your deck already has enough lands and enough removal, Fell the Profane may simply be unnecessary. MDFCs are great, but they are not free. Drawing a four-mana removal spell when you needed a one-mana answer can feel clunky.
The card is flexible. It is not magic glue for every black deck.
A Simple Buying Rule
Here is the rule I’d use:
If you are buying for Commander, get one nonfoil near mint copy at the lowest price from a reputable seller.
If you are buying for Modern or Legacy testing, do not buy a full playset until you have tested the card in your actual list.
A lot of players overbuy flexible cards because they look broadly useful. Fell the Profane is useful, but it is not an automatic four-of. In many 60-card decks, the first copy is much easier to justify than the fourth.
For testing deck slots before you buy, you can use the MTG.Cards deck builder to sketch out your list, check your curve, and see whether Fell the Profane is replacing a land, a removal spell, or a flex slot. That distinction matters more than people think.
If it replaces a land, your spell count goes up.
If it replaces removal, your mana base gets safer.
If it replaces a flex card, your deck gets more stable but maybe less explosive.
That is where the card gets interesting.
Price Target For Fell The Profane
As of late April 2026, a good target for a nonfoil Fell the Profane is roughly $3 to $4 before shipping.
Around $5 to $6 is normal from larger retailers.
Below $3 can be a good deal if shipping does not ruin it.
Foils cost more, often closer to the $5 to $11 range depending on seller and condition.
I would not stress over a one-dollar difference unless you are buying several copies. For one Commander deck, the more important question is whether the card belongs in the 99.
For a playset, price shop harder. Four copies at $5.99 is a very different purchase than four copies around $3.25.
Best Alternatives To Compare
Before buying Fell the Profane, compare it against the card it would replace.
For Commander, compare it to:
Hero’s Downfall
Murderous Rider
Hagra Mauling // Hagra Broodpit
Malakir Rebirth // Malakir Mire
Boggart Trawler // Boggart Bog
Deadly Rollick
Feed the Swarm
Baleful Mastery
Infernal Grasp
Go for the Throat
For faster formats, compare it to:
Fatal Push
Dismember
Cut Down
Sheoldred’s Edict
Go for the Throat
Snuff Out
March of Wretched Sorrow
The right comparison is not always “best removal spell.” Sometimes the right comparison is “worst land in my deck.” If Fell Mire is better than your weakest land and Fell the Profane is better than your weakest flex spell, the card earns its slot.
That is the MDFC math.
Bottom Line
The most competitive place to buy Fell the Profane is usually TCGplayer if you want the lowest price. Card Kingdom and Star City Games are better if you want a simpler retail purchase and do not mind paying more. eBay is worth checking for playsets, while your local game store is best when you want the card immediately.
As a card, Fell the Profane is good because it is flexible, not because it is the most efficient removal spell ever printed. Commander players should take it seriously. Modern and Legacy players should test before buying a playset.
The clean buy is simple: one nonfoil near mint copy for Commander, or a small test set if you are trying it in a tighter format.
FAQs
Where Can I Find The Cheapest Fell The Profane Cards?
TCGplayer is usually the best first stop for the cheapest Fell the Profane cards because it has many sellers competing on price. Check shipping before you assume the lowest listing is the best deal.
Is Fell The Profane Good In Commander?
Yes. Fell the Profane is strong in Commander because it works as both removal and a black land. That flexibility is the main reason it appears in so many EDH decks.
Should I Buy Foil Or Nonfoil Fell The Profane?
Buy nonfoil if you want the best value. Buy foil only if you like the look or the card is going into a deck you care about aesthetically.
Is Fell The Profane Good In Modern?
It can be playable in the right shell, but it is not usually as efficient as cheaper black removal. In Modern, the land side has to matter enough to justify the four-mana front side.
How Many Copies Of Fell The Profane Should I Buy?
For Commander, buy one. For 60-card formats, test before buying four. It is flexible, but that does not automatically make it a full playset card.